Are Protein Bars Good as Meal Replacements? (2024)

The answer, laid out bare, is YES! Protein bars can double up as meal replacements. But wait! Not every bar out there can classify as meal replacer. Read on as we explain it with science!

Imagine, the protein bar has to meet the requirements of protein, carbs, fibre, fats, vitamins and minerals that you get from food AND ensure you are not hungry an hour after eating it! Phew!

Just bear with us as we discuss this, scientifically!

What are meal replacers in the first place?

Traditionally meant for elderly or those who are extremely sick!

Meal replacements, a term popular in the US, are meant to be consumed as a replacement to meal and it could come in any form. A shake powder, a bar, or even in a liquid form.

Fun Fact: Meal replacement was intended for the elderly who frequently have a nutritional deficiency or for those people who can’t consume foods normally due to illness.

From there, meal replacements have now been synonymously associated for weight loss, weight control or in some cases, for performance sports.

Let’s agree, from old sick people to weight loss, meal replacements got a glamorous make-over!!

Are meal replacement protein bars for me? Is that what you are thinking?

The Answer is YES! If you are busy and might seem like skipping meals or eating junk, then it is surely for you too!

While it is commercialized or marketed for a certain section, meal replacements can be considered for everyone!

  • The uber busy sedentary working professional,
  • The health conscious with a time crunch,
  • All those doing intermittent fasting and wanting to break it and
  • If you are bored of consuming the regular meal shake things up with a meal replacement bar

Meal replacement protein bars can be considered by everyone, once a while for sure! Also, you indeed get the benefit of weight loss. Who doesn’t want that?!

Any and every bar can’t be a meal replacement bar!!!

Meal replacement products need to abide by certain international regulations. So not every protein bar is a meal replacement

But the real question is whether any health and protein bar can make the cut as meal replacements. The answer is clearly NO!

For a health/protein bar to qualify as a meal replacement, the Codex Alimentarious has set forth some standards. The replacements have to:

  • Have anywhere between 25 – 50% of total energy as protein. Safe lower range can be 30 grams.
  • 25 – 35% of the vitamins and minerals as suggested in the recommended dietary allowance

Well that might sound too technical but remember to read the labels of your health/protein bar pack. Anything that gives 12 grams, 15 grams even 20 grams of protein is out of the window. Look for the vitamin and mineral percentage as per RDA. Also, look at the amount of sugar in the bar. Many times, you will feel like having candy for lunch. Not desirable right.

Nutrition information check: look for grams of protein; percentage of vitamins and minerals as per RDA; amount of sugar and fibre. There, you are now empowered.

Shakes versus Bars: Where is the hunger satisfaction?

Bar easily score over shakes due to hunger satisfaction. When have you ever gulped your meal? Never. But when you chew, the brain gets a signal and you slowly start feeling full. The chewier the bar, the better for filling you up.

That’s why Max Protein Ultimate 30Gm bar can double up as meal replacement

It is tasty, gives the satisfaction of eating, super filling and covers the nutritional requirements of a meal.

Are Protein Bars Good as Meal Replacements? (1)

A safe, hygienic, nutritious, and tasty alternative to meals during virus ravaged times. Did we mention the mouthfeel is so chewy that you will get the satisfaction of eating a proper lunch? So the next time you feel like giving lunch a skip, don’t. Instead grab a

Max Protein Ultimate bar and power your way through the day.

A side note: Nothing, and we mean nothing can replace meals. Your chapatti, dal, subji, curd is enriching in variety and nutrition. Replacing meal is not sustainable for long and should be looked at as a short term alternative. Remember, eating a healthy balanced diet is the way to go for good health!

Are Protein Bars Good as Meal Replacements? (2024)

FAQs

Are Protein Bars Good as Meal Replacements? ›

Protein bars are quick and easy snacks that pack significant nutrition and calories per serving. While protein bars can be enjoyed regularly, consuming them as meal replacements or as your primary protein source isn't recommended.

Can I eat a protein bar as a meal replacement? ›

A protein bar may replace one meal or serve as dessert after your dinner meal; however, it's important that you eat other foods throughout the day as well so that you get adequate nutrients and calories for energy.

Are one protein bars a meal replacement? ›

ONE Bars are gluten-free and come in 15 different flavors—but no matter which flavors you choose, each bar provides 20 grams of protein. ONE protein bars are not intended to serve as meal replacements, but they can be a great way to increase your protein intake between meals.

Are protein bars good for weight loss? ›

Yes, low carb protein bars can be useful to a weight loss regimen. High in protein and fiber while low in carbohydrates, they can promote satiety and help you feel full longer, potentially reducing overall calorie intake. However, they should be consumed as part of a balanced diet and exercise program.

Is it OK to eat protein bars everyday? ›

A closer look at the ingredients and sugar levels in some of these bars can make you question whether they're a good idea to eat every day. While there's no problem with the occasional sugary snack or 'unhealthy' treat, eating certain types of protein bars every day might be problematic long term.

Is it safe to replace 2 meals a day with protein shakes? ›

Replacing your meals with protein shakes may be proven effective for weight loss, but it is not safe to replace all your meals with protein shakes due to the lack of vitamins and nutrients in each serving.

Is a protein bar a good substitute for a meal? ›

Most good meal replacement protein bar options contain about 20 grams of protein, 10 grams of fat, and 330 calories. If you're trying to lose weight, protein bars with no more than 10–15 grams of protein, 5 grams of fat, 230 calories, and at least 3 grams of fiber are best.

What happens if I only eat protein bars? ›

While protein bars have a time and place and can be helpful for many reasons, they can also inadvertently become a crutch for convenience. Relying too heavily on protein bars as meal replacements can lead to not eating whole foods at mealtimes and potential nutrient imbalances.

What protein bars skip a meal? ›

  • Jacked Factory.
  • IQBAR.
  • Send Bars.
  • Balanced Tiger.
  • KATE'S.
  • Orgain.
  • ProGo.
  • Power Crunch.

Are protein bars considered meals? ›

Although people often eat protein bars after a workout or as a meal replacement, those that are heavily processed or contain artificial sweetener do not supply the nutrients your body needs to get from a meal or to recover from exercising.

Should you eat a protein bar before or after a workout? ›

The most beneficial time to eat your protein bar is ideally within 30-60 minutes post workout. After your workout, it will help replenish energy stores and boost the muscle recovery and growth process. This is known as the 'anabolic window' and is thought to be the optimum time to get the most from your supplement.

Are Quest protein bars healthy? ›

Generally speaking, Quest protein bars can be a part of a complete and nutritious diet. They are a good source of protein and fiber and are low in sodium and sugar.

How many days a week should I eat a protein bar? ›

One or two protein bars a day are well within the recommended intake. But remember: the more protein-rich fruit and nut bars you eat, the more calories you're getting – something to bear in mind if you want to stick to a balanced diet.

What happens if you eat a protein bar without working out? ›

It is not bad to eat a protein bar without working out. However, if you are not careful and don't track your overall calories, it can lead to weight gain due to overeating. Protein bars tend to be high in calories, so consider tracking how many calories you eat throughout the day.

Why do I crave protein bars? ›

A craving for protein might simply mean you're not incorporating enough into your everyday diet. A lack of protein can cause you to feel weak, tired, and moody. Interestingly, a low protein level also can manifest as a sugar craving because of protein's role in regulating blood sugar levels.

Is it OK to drink protein as a meal replacement? ›

Replacing meals with protein shakes may help you lower your daily calories, which can help you lose weight. But in time you'll need to start eating solid food again. Eating solid food may cause excess weight to return if you don't make smart food choices.

Is pure protein bar a meal replacement? ›

These are not a meal replacement! At 180 to 220 calories per bar, you should treat Pure Protein Bars like a pre-workout or post-workout snack, or something to take the edge off in between meals.

Is eating a protein bar the same as drinking a protein shake? ›

Protein bars typically contain around 10-20 grams of protein per serving, which can be a suitable amount for a snack or a meal replacement option. On the other hand, protein shakes, especially those made with whey protein, can provide a higher protein content, often ranging from 20 to 30 grams per serving.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Amb. Frankie Simonis

Last Updated:

Views: 6140

Rating: 4.6 / 5 (56 voted)

Reviews: 95% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Amb. Frankie Simonis

Birthday: 1998-02-19

Address: 64841 Delmar Isle, North Wiley, OR 74073

Phone: +17844167847676

Job: Forward IT Agent

Hobby: LARPing, Kitesurfing, Sewing, Digital arts, Sand art, Gardening, Dance

Introduction: My name is Amb. Frankie Simonis, I am a hilarious, enchanting, energetic, cooperative, innocent, cute, joyous person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.